Download the E-books for free CEO tools, insights & decision frameworks

Who Do You Talk to When You Are Not Sure? The Hidden Cost of CEO Isolation

There is a category of conversation that family business leaders know needs to happen and almost never does. Not because they are avoiding it exactly, and not because they lack the intelligence or courage to have it. But because of who would be in the room. 

The conversation about succession. About whether the next generation is genuinely ready. About what the founder actually wants, as opposed to what they think they should want. About the roles and the authority and who is really running what. About what happens to the business, and to the family, if the current arrangement continues unchanged. 

These conversations are almost impossible to have honestly inside a family business, because the people who most need to hear them are also the people with the most personal stake in how they land. 

This article is about why that is, what it costs, and what it takes to have the conversations that actually move things forward. 

The research behind the feeling 

Harvard Business Review research into senior leadership found that 61% of CEOs say they feel lonely in the role. Of those, half say it affects their performance. That is not a study about mental health. It is a study about decision quality, and it draws a direct line between isolation at the top and the quality of the calls that get made there. 

The figure tends to land differently depending on who reads it. For some CEOs it is a relief,  confirmation that what they have been experiencing is not a personal failing but a structural feature of the role. For others it is uncomfortable, because acknowledging it would require admitting something they have been managing privately for a long time. 

Either way, the research is consistent with what I see in practice. The higher a CEO climbs, the narrower the range of conversations they can have honestly. And the decisions that require the most honest thinking are almost always the ones that are hardest to have that thinking about with the people who are closest to them. 

Why the usual sources of support do not quite work 

Most CEOs have people around them. They have teams, boards, advisers, peer networks, mentors, friends who run businesses. The problem is not a lack of people. The problem is that none of those relationships quite creates the space for the kind of honest, unmanaged thinking that genuinely difficult decisions require. 

The team 

The team looks to the CEO for certainty. That is not a criticism of the team, it is what a team needs from its leader. But it means that the CEO who shares genuine uncertainty with their team is doing something different from thinking out loud. They are making a leadership communication, with all the downstream consequences that involves. The team will read it, respond to it, and act on it. Once the CEO says something to the team, it has become a signal. 

The board 

The board has its own agenda and its own perspective on the business. A board member who is there to represent investors, or who has their own view on the strategy, is not a neutral thinking partner. They bring their own reading to every conversation, and the CEO knows it. Sharing genuine uncertainty with the board is a different thing from exploring a question privately. It is a governance conversation, with all the implications that carries. 

Advisers 

Advisers give advice. That is their job and they do it well. But advice is different from challenge. An adviser who is engaged to help with a specific problem will bring their expertise to that problem and recommend a course of action. They are not there to ask the CEO whether they are framing the problem correctly in the first place, or whether the assumption underneath the question needs to be examined before the question is answered. 

Peers and friends 

Peers who run businesses can offer perspective, but they have limited time and their own version of the same problem. Nobody really wants to come home after a ten-hour day and then fully unpack a complex business dilemma with their husband or wife. And peers, however well-intentioned, are drawing on their own experience of their own business, which may or may not map onto what the CEO in front of them is actually dealing with. 

The structural sources of isolation 

What makes CEO isolation structural rather than personal is that it is built into the role itself. The same dynamics that create the CEO bottleneck, where everything flows back to one person because the team has learned to depend on their availability and judgement, also create the isolation. The CEO who is expected to have the answers cannot easily be seen not to have them. The leader of the pack cannot be uncertain in front of the pack without it being read as a signal. 

This is not a weakness. It is the job. The CEO who projects certainty when they need to, holds the team’s confidence, and manages the board’s expectations is doing what the role requires. The question is not whether that is right, it largely is. The question is what happens to the uncertainty that cannot be shown. Where does it go? 

In most cases, it stays inside. It gets carried privately, worked through alone, or deferred until it resolves itself or becomes unavoidable. And the decisions that should have been pressure-tested against a genuinely challenging perspective get made in isolation instead, with whatever the CEO could assemble internally on a busy day. 

When isolation affects decision quality 

McKinsey research into decision quality found that the single strongest predictor of good strategic decision-making was not experience, intelligence or access to data. It was the habit of seeking out people who would genuinely challenge the thinking. This connects directly to the broader question of AI and CEO decision-making, where the risk is not bad answers but the gradual atrophy of the judgement muscle when it is not exercised properly. 

The pattern that emerges from the research is consistent: CEOs who have somewhere to pressure-test their thinking before it becomes a decision make significantly better strategic calls than those who do not. Not occasionally. Consistently, and by a measurable margin. 

The cost of isolation is not usually dramatic. It rarely shows up as a single catastrophic decision that could obviously have been avoided. It shows up as a gradual drift in the quality of the calls that get made, positions held more firmly than the evidence warrants, risks underestimated because they were not examined by someone with no stake in minimising them, opportunities missed because the question of whether to pursue them was never really tested. 

The CEO who has somewhere honest to think tends to make fewer of those decisions. Not because they are smarter or more experienced, but because their thinking gets challenged before it becomes a commitment. 

I have lived this 

I started doing this work because of my own experience of needing it and not being able to find it. 

In 2007, I was running an online retail business that had grown fast and then started to slow down. We had private equity in. The business had been doing well. And then it started to slow, and I could not understand why. I could not go to my investors and say: there is a significant amount of your money in this business and I do not really know what is happening to it. You cannot have that conversation. 

I had a non-executive director, but he had been put there to represent the investors. He said to me: James, I can only go so far in this conversation. I have my responsibilities. I cannot go as far as you want to go. 

And I remember sitting at my desk one day, metaphorically with my head in my hands, thinking: I just need someone to talk to. The business felt like a thousand-piece jigsaw, broken, with no picture on the box. I did not need someone to do it for me. I just needed someone to say, look, there are lots of blue bits with straight edges over there. Start with those. 

I could not find anyone. 

When I eventually exited that business, the phone started to ring from people who described a version of what I had experienced. And I recognised it immediately. That is why I do this work. Not because I read about it. Because I lived it. And because I know, from the inside, what it costs to make important decisions without anywhere honest to think them through. 

AI and CEO decision-making with a business leader reviewing AI-generated insights and considering strategic options.

Lonely in a crowded room 

The isolation of the CEO is not the isolation of someone alone. It is, as one of my clients once put it, the isolation of being the loneliest person in a crowded room. 

I worked with the chief executive of a business close to a billion in turnover. FTSE 250. He had a board, an executive team, a chair, and every resource and governance structure that a large listed company provides. By any external measure, he was one of the most well-supported CEOs in the country. 

And he reached out and said: I could do with spending a couple of hours a month with someone like you. 

That was all we did. A couple of hours a month. But it gave him somewhere to unpack the things that were genuinely difficult to carry alone. Almost always it was about his C-suite, half a dozen people, all paid half a million a year, some performing well and some not. Dealing with that honestly is not a conversation you can have with the board. So he was carrying it in the gap between knowing something needed to change and having to make the call publicly. 

He was lonely. Not in spite of everything around him. Because of the specific role that everything around him required him to play. 

Book a session

What actually helps 

What genuinely helps CEO isolation is not more advice, more data, or more people in the room. It is a very specific kind of relationship: what I think of as a CEO Decision Partner. Someone completely outside the governance structure of the business. Someone with no financial stake in the outcome and no relationship to protect. Someone who will tell the CEO what they actually think, challenge the assumption underneath the question, and ask the thing that everyone else in the room has learned not to ask. 

This is different from coaching in the traditional sense, where the coach asks questions but does not offer a view. Most of my clients are not looking for someone to ask them questions they could ask themselves. They have enough of those. They are looking for someone who has been around long enough, seen enough businesses from the inside, and has enough genuine perspective to actually challenge the thinking rather than reflect it back. 

It is also different from mentoring, which tends to be based on the mentor’s own experience and can drift towards telling the CEO what the mentor would have done. The most useful thinking partnership is one that holds the CEO’s specific situation, their business, their team, their constraints, their decision, and challenges it on its own terms. 

One of my clients, a very smart woman who had built a highly successful law practice, said to me once: James, I wish you would create the Lonely CEO Club, because I would want to be a member. I actually registered the domain name, because I thought she had named something real. Even at the top of a successful business, with talented people around her and a practice she had built from nothing, she was making her most important decisions alone. 

That is the hidden cost of CEO isolation. And it is more common, and more commercially significant, than almost anyone talks about openly. 

If you want to understand where isolation and decision-making drag may be affecting your business, the CEO Scorecard is a useful starting point: [CEO SCORECARD] 

Book a call

What actually helps 

What genuinely helps CEO isolation is not more advice, more data, or more people in the room. It is a very specific kind of relationship: what I think of as a CEO Decision Partner. Someone completely outside the governance structure of the business. Someone with no financial stake in the outcome and no relationship to protect. Someone who will tell the CEO what they actually think, challenge the assumption underneath the question, and ask the thing that everyone else in the room has learned not to ask. 

This is different from coaching in the traditional sense, where the coach asks questions but does not offer a view. Most of my clients are not looking for someone to ask them questions they could ask themselves. They have enough of those. They are looking for someone who has been around long enough, seen enough businesses from the inside, and has enough genuine perspective to actually challenge the thinking rather than reflect it back. 

It is also different from mentoring, which tends to be based on the mentor’s own experience and can drift towards telling the CEO what the mentor would have done. The most useful thinking partnership is one that holds the CEO’s specific situation, their business, their team, their constraints, their decision, and challenges it on its own terms. 

One of my clients, a very smart woman who had built a highly successful law practice, said to me once: James, I wish you would create the Lonely CEO Club, because I would want to be a member. I actually registered the domain name, because I thought she had named something real. Even at the top of a successful business, with talented people around her and a practice she had built from nothing, she was making her most important decisions alone. 

That is the hidden cost of CEO isolation. And it is more common, and more commercially significant, than almost anyone talks about openly. 

If you want to understand where isolation and decision-making drag may be affecting your business, the CEO Scorecard is a useful starting point: [CEO SCORECARD LINK] 

Frequently asked questions 

Why do so many CEOs feel lonely in the role? 

Because the structural requirements of the role, projecting certainty, managing the board, leading the team, make it very difficult to be genuinely uncertain with the people around them. The range of conversations a CEO can have honestly contracts as their accountability increases. This is not a personal failing. It is a feature of the role. 

Does CEO loneliness actually affect business performance? 

Yes. Harvard Business Review research found that of the 61% of CEOs who report feeling lonely in the role, half say it affects their performance. McKinsey research found that CEOs who regularly seek external challenge make significantly better strategic decisions than those who do not. The link between isolation and decision quality is well supported. 

Who should a CEO talk to when they are not sure? 

Someone completely outside the governance structure of the business, with no financial stake in the outcome and no relationship to protect. This is different from advisers, who give advice. Different from board members, who have their own agenda. Different from the team, who look to the CEO for answers. The most useful thinking partner is one who can challenge the assumption underneath the question without any of those dynamics getting in the way. 

Is CEO isolation the same as loneliness? 

Not quite. CEO isolation is structural, it is built into the role. The CEO may be surrounded by people and still isolated, because the conversations that matter most cannot be had honestly with the people closest to them. Loneliness is the personal experience of that isolation. Both are real, and both have consequences for the quality of the decisions that get made. 

What is a CEO Decision Partner? 

An experienced external adviser who works with the CEO as a genuine thinking partner rather than as an adviser in the traditional sense. Someone who will challenge the thinking, ask the question everyone else has learned not to ask, and do so with no agenda except helping the CEO arrive at the best decision for their business. 

How is a CEO Decision Partner different from a coach or mentor? 

A coach typically asks questions but does not offer a view. A mentor draws primarily on their own experience. A CEO Decision Partner combines genuine challenge with enough business experience to engage with the specific situation, not just to reflect the CEO’s thinking back to them, but to pressure-test it against a perspective that has seen enough to be genuinely useful. 

Author

Our website uses cookies to provide you with the best browsing experience.
You can view our Website terms of Use here.
By continuing to use our website, you agree to our use of cookies.
Our Cookie Policy can be found here.